
Do You Really Need Surgery for a Torn ACL?
What the evidence says about non-surgical ACL management, and the 3 steps to take after an ACL tear.
If you've just torn your ACL, you've probably been told surgery is the only way back to sport. For many people in Australia, that's the default path. But a growing body of research shows that exercise-based rehab without surgery can lead to similar long-term results, and that a torn ACL may even be able to heal on its own.
Here's what the evidence says, and what to do in the first few months after an ACL injury.
Australia loves ACL surgery
- 43%: the rise in ACL reconstruction (ACLR) surgery in Australia between 2000 and 2015, one of the highest rates in the world.
- About 9 in 10 ACL injuries in Australia end up having surgery.
Yet the research suggests people do about as well in the long run whether they have surgery or rehab with exercise alone.
Three common myths
- Myth: "You need surgery to return to sport." The evidence: return to sport is similar with or without surgery.
- Myth: "Without surgery, you're more likely to injure your knee again." The evidence: rates of further knee injury are similar with or without surgery.
- Myth: "Without surgery, you're more likely to get knee arthritis." The evidence: rates of knee osteoarthritis are similar with or without surgery.
With or without surgery, studies show no difference in:
- Knee instability
- Further injuries
- Function and strength
- Knee osteoarthritis
- Long-term quality of life, pain and symptoms
- Fear of re-injury
- Physical activity levels
- Return to sport
Can a torn ACL heal?
It was long believed that a ruptured ACL had very little ability to heal. A 2023 study by Filbay and colleagues challenged that: 90% of people managed with the Cross Bracing Protocol showed signs of ACL healing on MRI, with potential for the ligament to heal completely.
What is the Cross Bracing Protocol?
Researchers think two things can stop a torn ACL from healing: the gap between the two torn ends, and the knee movement that happens during normal rehab. Both may stop new connective tissue from bridging the gap.
The Cross Bracing Protocol tackles this by:
- Bracing the knee in a position that brings the two torn ends of the ACL closer together.
- Holding the knee still in that position so new tissue can bridge the gap.
- Gradually working towards taking the brace off at around 12 weeks.
This protocol must be guided by your medical team and rehab provider.
The biggest factor: quality rehab
Whether or not you have surgery, the quality of your rehab is the biggest factor in how well you recover. Poor rehab can lead to poor results either way. That's why it's important to have a qualified health professional, such as an exercise physiologist, guiding your rehab.
Surgery vs exercise rehab: the pros and cons
ACL surgery + rehab
Pros
- Most people have a stable knee after surgery
- More research to guide rehab and recovery timelines
- More clinicians are experienced in post-surgery rehab
Cons
- Risk of surgical complications
- Risk of the graft re-rupturing, which is linked to poorer outcomes
- The torn ACL is removed, so it can never heal on its own
- Usually costs more than non-surgical rehab
- A period of more pain, swelling, poor knee function and activity limits
- Return to sport not recommended until 9–12 months after surgery
- Possible pain, weakness or other problems where the graft was taken from
- Weakness, poor muscle activation and poor knee function can last beyond 12 months
- May reduce knee proprioception (your sense of knee position) compared with non-surgical rehab
- More knee swelling and cartilage changes within 2 years than non-surgical rehab
Exercise-only rehab
Pros
- The torn ACL may heal naturally, which may lead to better outcomes
- Rehab before surgery is linked to better results if you do have surgery
- Putting off the decision about surgery doesn't lead to worse outcomes
- You may avoid surgery, its costs and its risks
Cons
- Some people still have an unstable knee and are advised to have surgery after trying rehab
- If you then need surgery, total time to return to sport and activities can be longer
- May lead to a looser knee, though this doesn't always mean it feels unstable during activity
Good to know: if you try rehab first and later need surgery, that time isn't wasted. It works as pre-surgery rehab, which is linked to better results after the operation.
What to do after an ACL tear: 3 steps
- Start education and exercise-based rehab to get to a "quiet knee".
- Hold off on deciding about surgery until your knee is quiet (about 3 months).
- Decide whether to keep going with exercise rehab or have surgery, based on how your knee is going and how happy you are with your progress. Delaying surgery does not lead to worse outcomes.
What is a "quiet knee"?
A quiet knee has:
- Less than 2/10 pain during everyday activities
- Full range when straightening the knee
- More than 120° of bend
- No more than moderate swelling
- A normal walking pattern
How Activate can help
Our exercise physiologists can guide your ACL rehab from day one, whether you're trying non-surgical management, preparing for surgery or recovering after it. We'll help you get to a quiet knee, track your progress and support you to make an informed decision with your doctor or surgeon.
Ready to get started? Book an appointment with our Exercise Physiology team at Activate Allied Health, 1/131 Bulleen Road, Balwyn North. Call us on (03) 8849 9795 or click Book Online at the top of this page.
This article is general information only and isn't a substitute for personal advice from your doctor or health professional.
Reference
Filbay, S. R., Dowsett, M., Chaker Jomaa, M., Rooney, J., Sabharwal, R., Lucas, P., Van Den Heever, A., Kazaglis, J., Merlino, J., Moran, M., Allwright, M., Kuah, D. E. K., Durie, R., Roger, G., Cross, M., & Cross, T. (2023). Healing of acute anterior cruciate ligament rupture on MRI and outcomes following non-surgical management with the Cross Bracing Protocol. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 57(23), 1490–1497. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2023-106931










